Welcome to Tisha's Fine Dining
Nestled in the charming streets of Cape May, Tisha's Fine Dining offers an exquisite fusion of Italian, American, and seafood cuisine. With a commitment to freshness and flavor, their dinner menu features standout dishes like Seafood Risotto, seasoned to perfection, and the savory Lobster Bisque that keeps patrons returning. Guests rave about the generous portion sizes and the delightful ambiance, making it the ideal spot for romantic evenings or celebratory gatherings. Tisha's is a BYOB establishment, enhancing the dining experience with a welcoming atmosphere. Enjoy memorable meals crafted with care, ensuring each visit is as delightful as the last.
-
322 Washington St, Cape May, NJ 08204 Hotline: (609) 884-9119
Welcome to Tisha's Fine Dining, a culinary gem nestled on 322 Washington St, Cape May, NJ. This exceptional restaurant artfully blends Italian, American, and seafood influences, creating a unique dining experience that has earned a loyal following among locals and visitors alike. Whether you're seeking a cozy dinner for two or a grand celebration with friends, Tisha’s promises to delight your palate with its thoughtfully crafted menu.
Unforgettable Dishes
- Cajun Fried Oysters - A must-try, these spicy, hand-breaded oysters are perfectly fried and served with delicious house-made pepper mayo, priced at $16.
- Seafood Risotto - This rich and creamy dish boasts jumbo shrimp, local sea scallops, and little neck clams, making it a highlight at $42.
- Thai Salmon and Shrimp - Grilled Atlantic salmon accompanied by fresh shrimp, red mashed potatoes, and green beans in a sweet Thai chili sauce for $36.
- Lobster Bisque - A delightful starter priced at $17, praised for its luxurious texture and flavors.
- Fried Calamari - Lightly fried and tossed with roasted peppers and capers, this dish is perfect for sharing at $16.
What stands out at Tisha’s is the restaurant's commitment to freshness and quality. Many diners echo the sentiment of Kathy G., who highlights the “on-point” service and inviting ambiance, which makes reservations highly recommended on weekends. It’s not just about the food; it’s about the entire experience.
Atmosphere and Excellence
The atmosphere at Tisha's blends elegance with a relaxed vibe, making it ideal for romantic evenings or family gatherings. As Ashley G. perfectly describes, enjoying a meal outside on a summer night while people-watching adds a special charm to the dining experience. The restaurant's BYOB policy invites diners to bring their favorite wines, enhancing the personalized experience.
Diners like William G. confess that the flavors are unforgettable. The complimentary bread served at the start sets the tone for what’s to come, while the attentive staff, as noted by Christina S., ensures every aspect of your meal is satisfying—from the fresh salads to the impressive entrees.
Given the consistently positive feedback, it’s clear that Tisha's is more than just a restaurant; it’s a staple in the Cape May dining scene, celebrated for its exceptional food, warm service, and inviting ambiance. As Thomas G. shares, every visit feels like a dependable retreat into culinary bliss. Give Tisha's Fine Dining a visit, but remember—reservations are your key to this delightful treasure!
For reservations, call (609) 884-9119 and prepare yourself for an experience that will linger in your flavor memory long after the last bite.
Never have gotten a poor meal here. The service is on point in high season. The ambiance is very nice. Don't try to go without a reservation or make one well in advance!
Great food and service! Everything was made to order, which means that our part of 8 lunch was close to 3 hours, but the food was all made well - clean and not overly seasoned. Service was also great. A safe and great option for a restaurant on the mall.
I'm so happy that we ate at Tisha's. I had really good memories of eating here at least 10 years prior, and I'm glad to report that nothing has changed. Food is still incredible. This is one of the most popular restaurants in Cape May for good reason! Apps are where it's at! We shared the scallop risotto, calamari and rice balls and everything was standout. Portions are generous for apps as well! Service was also great. Don't forget to bring a bottle and make a reservation. Without one, you likely won't get a table on a weekend. For a quality meal in Cape May this is a must.
Love Tisha's and loved my scallops and risotto. I adore sitting outside Tisha's on a summer night and enjoying my food, my conversations, and watching people pass that are enjoying their night also. The ambience is so romantic and cozy. I had a lovely time with my boyfriend and we look for to going back. Restaurant is BYOB.
Hands down my favorite restaurant in Cape May. Highly recommend a reservation. They're BYOB. We brought a bottle of champagne and they brought us the glasses and a ice bucket for it. They offer bread complimentary. The calamari and Lobster Bisque are a great way to start the meal. Only restaurant that rivals their bisque is Fredas. I always get the Seafood Risotto. I'll put a picture up.
This restaurant has become a staple for us. Not only is the atmosphere, service and food quality delightful but with all the competition of places to fine dine, it's nice to find one you grow to depend on. BYOB is option! We haven't had a bad meal ever. My wife longs for the Halibut dish perched atop of mashed potatoes and green beans smothered in some creamy gravy-of-a-sauce-goodness is simply different in a subtle brilliant way. I had a Chioppino style dish which was a special that night. I ate all of my dinner only to leave freckles of marinara broth as traces of my experience. No desert this night because we frequent a spot out back. Great meal at Tisha's but $$$ so fair warning.
Excellent food. Severs were kind, thoughtful and served with a smile. I think the restaurant could use an extra hand or two or have less tables per server to reduce pressure on nights where they have more people. I had the watercress salad and the mushroom risotto. Both were good. Vibe is relaxed elegance. They have indoor and outdoor seating. We really enjoyed ourselves. Will go back. FYI- This is BYOB.
We had a delicious dinner at Tisha's. We arrived for our reservation and front dining room was packed, so opted for the smaller, quieter back room! Tisha's is a BYOB, so don't forget to bring a bottle! We started with clam chowder, burrata over arugula, and beets/gorgonzola over mixed greens. All were very good and fresh! For dinner, my boyfriend just really wanted plain crab cakes, so ordered 2 of the appetizer portions. The 2 arrived on plates as individual servings. Would have been easy and looked better to just put 2 on the one plate. Mom and I split the Thai salmon with shrimp over potatoes and green beans. A very nice sized portion, I'm so glad that we shared! We didn't even look at dessert bc we had to meet family. Overall, a great meal with good service. Despite being packed inside and out, Gavin did a good job trying to stay on top of things! It was a nice evening!